Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Vini B's avatar

In Brazil, the central bank's mandate is to meet the inflation target. Since 2023, inflation has been above the midpoint of the target range in 45 months and above the upper bound in 21 months. It is currently above the upper bound.

The government could raise the inflation target, allowing the central bank to lower interest rates. If raising the target or cutting rates does not set off an inflationary spiral, it could be a win-win situation. Throughout this period, however, the current government has done nothing along these lines and has focused solely on complaining about high interest rates and calling for cuts — much like Trump does.

As for fiscal policy, it is unlikely that the government will pursue structural spending cuts. Roughly 90% of the federal budget consists of mandatory expenditures, while the remainder barely covers the cost of keeping the government running. The list of handouts and free benefits keeps growing. Brazil is gradually losing its demographic dividend, the social security deficit is widening, much of the economy is indexed, and the government is likely to continue granting real increases in the minimum wage, which in turn drive up other expenditures linked to it, such as pension and social assistance benefits.

There are also other factors adding fuel to inflation: increases in existing social benefits, the creation of new ones, and various credit programs, whether through the government acting as a guarantor or providing subsidized credit.

So yeah, it'd be lower interest rates WITH fiscal loosening.

scott free's avatar

The uproar is being caused by government officials and politicians using Resende's text and interpretation of the FTPL as a crutch on which to put all the blame on monetary policy (as always, the Executive branch treats the Central Bank as an enemy who is trying to sabotage the economy with high rates), and as such be free to spend as they please.

That is exactly why Resende's proposal can't possibly work; the FISCAL part of the Fiscal Theory is being thown in the garbage as is convenient.

47 more comments...

Ready for more?